Doc Love
GCN Live.com
Doc Love answers a letter from a guy that feels left high-and-dry by his former girlfriend.

Hey Doc,
I’m having a confusing and frustrating week due to my breakup with Scarlett. I’m 27 and she’s 21, and we’ve known each other for five years, but we’ve only been dating for two months. I admire your coaching, and I intend to buy your book.
Before dating me, Scarlett had a four-year relationship that she broke off because she felt that it wasn’t going anywhere. We clicked completely and found that we shared lots of interests, had great chemistry, cared for one another and pretty much were compatible in every way. The problems began when I was invited to her aunt’s house for dinner. Scarlett showed up late and acted extremely cold to me. This was a side of her I never saw before. I kept to myself most of the night because I felt stranded in an awkward position. Finally she sat me down in a secluded room and told me that she was breaking up with me because she couldn’t see a future for us. She threw in that I don’t motivate her enough and she felt that we were going to end up being lazy, fat people on the couch. (By the way, neither of us is overweight, and I go to the gym faithfully.) She then commented that we are not compatible and that nothing can fix it. I told her I wasn’t accepting that answer because she wasn’t making sense. She then commented that I was the greatest but she’s not, and that I should find someone else. My heart was broken.
After about a week I sent her an e-mail asking her to clarify the reason she suddenly broke up with me. I told her that I was willing to work on any issues we might have if she’s willing to, and that I felt that we really had something awesome going. I asked her to think about it and to get back to me. Through mutual friends I know she didn’t go back to her ex.
A few days later Scarlett replied that she just felt we weren’t compatible, but gave no reason why. She added that maybe we could be friends again or possibly go back to what we had.
Doc, I’m totally lost. Our relationship was great. I kept Scarlett interested, I wasn’t needy and I didn’t see any compatibility issues. I really like Scarlett and would love to continue dating her, but I just don’t understand her point of view. Is she still hung up on her ex? Why did she suddenly turn cold on me? Is she confused about what she really wants in a relationship? Am I the problem? Why couldn’t she have talked to me about these issues before breaking my heart?
Gibby – who feels like crying
Hi Gibby,
The first problem you’ve got is that you’re involved with 21-year-old girl. And if you knew my book – which you don’t – you’d understand that between the ages of 18 to 22, girls fall in and out of love every five minutes. You should be dating a 24 to 27 year old.
When Scarlett froze you out at her aunt’s house, you should have just walked out. You should have thanked the lady for her hospitality and hit the bricks. Like my cousin Fast Eddie Love from East L.A. says, “Once I’m dissed, I walk.”
When Scarlett announced that she saw no future for the two of you, you should have said, “You know, that’s exactly what I was thinking,” and added, “We had a great run.” Then you should have got up and walked straight out and never talked to her again. Then, most importantly, you should have immediately gotten my book — which you don’t have, and which you just “might” buy — and figured out why Scarlett dumped you.
Scarlett is afraid that you and she will end up being lazy, fat people on the couch? And I thought I’d heard them all! But neither of you are out of shape, so if what you’re saying is true, what Scarlett claims has absolutely nothing to do with the breakup. What she’s not telling you is that you lowered her Interest Level because you didn’t use the principles in my book — that’s what she’s really saying to you in Womanese. You lowered Scarlett’s Interest Level gradually over time and then she had to come up with an excuse to get rid of you because women don’t come right out and tell you that you lowered their interest slowly. They have to come up with something that doesn’t make any sense, like “We’re going to be lazy and fat in our old age.” Again, you would have figured this out if you had “The System.”
And so your heart was broken – but even then you didn’t buy my book. What does Scarlett have to do, drive a bulldozer through your house before you realize what’s going on, before you catch on that she doesn’t dig you?
Now let me get this straight. You sent this girl an email asking for clarification why she deep-sixed you? That’s begging, Gibby! Why are you on your knees? Don’t you get it – you’re OUT. Scarlett’s in the arms of a new guy and you’re begging by email? You might think that you had something awesome, but the truth is that you turned this girl off over a period of time. This is what you’re not getting. Like my cousin General Love says, “Disasters don’t just happen overnight.”
And why are you blabbing to mutual friends? They’re going to cover for Scarlett, pal, I got news for you. How do you know that these mutual friends are telling you the truth about what’s really going on? To boot, they can’t wait to tell Scarlett that you’re begging on the side! (By the way, Gibby, don’t rush out and get my book. You wouldn’t want to do that. It’s better for you to remain in pain and misery than realize all the mistakes you made to turn this girl off!)
Scarlett told you there was a chance you two could go back to what you had? Like my Uncle Jethro Love says, “The chance that she’ll take you back is about as good as you gettin’ hit by lightnin’!”
My friend, you might not have seen any problems whatsoever with Scarlett, but you didn’t have my book. And because of that you were not reading all the signals and you couldn’t keep her interested in you. In your mind she was interested in you, but you didn’t use the techniques in “The System” — which you might just get around to buying in a couple of years.
It doesn’t really matter what Scarlett says about what happened between the two of you. THE ONLY IMPORTANT POINT IS THAT SHE DOESN’T WANT TO BE WITH YOU. You’re out, guy. And none of this has anything to do with her ex. It only has to do with YOU. She didn’t turn “suddenly” cold on you. She’s been thinking about getting rid of you for a while. She’s not confused at all about what she wants in a relationship. You’re the one who’s confused. Scarlett knows for sure that she wants to get rid of you and you’re confused about what you did to lose her and how to get her back.
So yes, Gibby, you are the one who’s the problem. You are the ONLY problem. It’s all your fault. What happened has nothing to do with Scarlett or her ex or your mutual friends. Know why she couldn’t talk to you before breaking up? Because women don’t do that. They just say au revoir. That’s also explained in my book, which you’re thinking about buying sometime in the future.
Remember, guys: you might think you just got dumped today, but you were on your way out before you realized it.
Doc Love is the host of
The Doc Love Show, which airs on GCN Saturdays 9:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. Central Time. Listen to the show
On Demand. For more information on Doc Love and his relationship services, visit
DocLove.com
Like GCN Live on Facebook and follow on Twitter for more great news, opinions, and announcements from GCN Live’s hosts and staff.